Extro's
Bergamotto di Calabria is fantastic soap/croap: both in performance and scent.
Razorock's
XXX is another AdP Colonia dupe, but a better performer than
Piacenza
Acqua di Parma have the OG
Colonia; expensive but amazing
Santa Maria Novella's
Crema de Barbara is a tobacco/eucalyptus/menthol croap that is pricey, but you get a big tub and like the AdP it really lasts
Razorocks
Santa Maria del Fiore is a SMN dupe; the soap is on par with SMNs, but their aftershave is no match for SMN's exquisite
Tobacco Toscana lotion.
I'd recommend you pick up both the Razorock versions, and if you like them go all in with the AdP croap and SMN aftershave.